An Honest Comparison

Zeffy and All In One Nonprofit do different jobs. Many organizations use both.

Zeffy is a free way to take donations and sell tickets. All In One Nonprofit is how you run the organization behind them: the board, the filings, the books, the people, the programs and the reports. If you are deciding between them, you are probably asking the wrong question. Here is what each one does, what each one does not, and how they fit together.

Jump to the side by side comparison
Zeffy facts on this page come from Zeffy's own public pages (support.zeffy.com, What is Zeffy?, support.zeffy.com, How Zeffy is 100% free) as read on November 21, 2026. "Not listed" means we did not find it there on that date; it may exist. All In One Nonprofit is not affiliated with Zeffy and receives nothing from it. Prices and features change, so confirm current terms with Zeffy directly. Product names belong to their owners.Facts checked November 21, 2026. Next check due by February 21, 2027. See something out of date? Email [email protected].

What Zeffy does well

Credit where it is due. Zeffy has built a strong set of fundraising tools and charges the organization nothing for them.

Free to the organization

No platform fee, no transaction fee, no card fee, no subscription. Zeffy pays its costs from a voluntary contribution it asks each donor to add at checkout, and the organization receives the full gift either way. Some donors and some boards like that model and some do not; that is a choice for your organization, and we think you should make it with your eyes open.

Every way to raise money online

Donation forms with recurring giving, event tickets with door scanning, raffles, auctions, peer to peer campaigns, an online store, memberships with renewals, and Tap to Pay on a phone for in-person gifts. If your need is a fundraiser, Zeffy covers it.

A capable donor record and email

Contacts created from each payment with giving history, segments and notes, automatic year-end tax receipts, and email newsletters with templates, scheduling and tracking.

Open in several countries

Registered nonprofits and charities in the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, Ireland, Australia and Germany.

Where All In One Nonprofit picks up

Taking the money is one part of the work. Zeffy does not set out to run the rest of the organization, and that is where All In One Nonprofit works.

The board

Meetings, minutes, attendance, terms, officers, committees, the handbook, policies, e-signatures and a board report built from your real numbers. We did not find board tools on Zeffy's public pages.

Compliance and filings

A calendar of state and federal deadlines, Form 990 preparation, charitable registration, a document retention schedule and an audit trail. We did not find a filing calendar or Form 990 tools on Zeffy's public pages.

The books

A ledger, a budget against actual, restricted funds, and the financial report your treasurer presents. Zeffy connects to QuickBooks Online; it does not keep the books.

People

Staff records, time off, reviews and credentials; volunteer applications, screenings, hours and expiring background checks. We did not find staff or volunteer records on Zeffy's public pages.

Programs, participants and impact

Case management with a public intake form, impact measurement by program, grant proposals with reporting deadlines, and an annual report and periodic reports on your letterhead. We did not find case management or impact measurement on Zeffy's public pages.

More than one organization

A workspace across every organization you belong to, consultant and specialist seats, and each additional legal organization added to the same subscription at half the plan price. Ask Zeffy how it handles several related organizations.

Side by side

AreaZeffyAll In One Nonprofit
Online donationsYes. Free to the organization; donors are asked to add a contribution to Zeffy.Yes. Your own Stripe or PayPal, no platform fee, no donor prompt; you pay your processor's card fees.
Tickets, raffles, auctions, storeYes, all four.Event tickets with QR codes and door check-in, silent auctions with online bidding, an online store, and raffle record keeping (no online raffle ticket sales).
Peer to peerYes.Yes. Team fundraising with a shareable page for each supporter.
MembershipsTiers, member information and renewals.Dues, roster, join page, member portal, directory, officers and roles.
Donor recordsStrong basics, built from each payment.Giving history, an engagement score, a stewardship queue, letters on letterhead, retention views and year-end statements.
EmailBuilt in.Newsletters to your own people, plus a connection to your MailerLite, Mailchimp or Brevo account.
Board and governanceNot listed.Yes.
Compliance and filingsNot listed.Yes.
Finances and budgetConnects to QuickBooks Online.Yes, with a one-way connection to QuickBooks if you keep it.
HR and volunteersNot listed.Yes.
Programs, cases, impact, grant writingNot listed.Yes.
Documents and e-signatureNot listed.A document library, a retention schedule and e-signature.
Reports on letterheadNot listed.Monthly, quarterly and annual, in Word.
Several organizations, consultantsNot listed.Yes.
PriceFree to the organization.All In One Nonprofit Essentials $49 a month or $499 a year; All In One Nonprofit Complete $199 a month or $1,999 a year. No platform fee on gifts. See pricing.

Using both

Nonprofits can fundraise on Zeffy and manage the rest of their organization on All In One Nonprofit, and that works. Keep your Zeffy forms if your donors are used to them. On My Organization, an owner or Admin can connect the Zeffy account, and from then on gifts collected on Zeffy arrive in your donor records and your books here as they come in. Gifts from before the connection come in only if you choose a start date. Zeffy has already sent the tax receipt, so here you send the thank-you letter on your letterhead.

If you would rather take donations without asking your donors for anything extra, the giving page here runs on your own Stripe or PayPal account with no platform fee and no prompt. Both paths end in the same place: every gift in one set of records that the rest of the organization can use.

Which one is for you

Choose Zeffy alone if

Your organization is a fundraiser and not much else: a one-event charity, a booster club that needs a donate button and tickets, a group with no board meetings to run and no filings to track. Zeffy will do that well and for free.

Choose All In One Nonprofit if

You have a board, a filing calendar, a budget, volunteers or staff, programs with participants, and funders who ask for reports. Take donations here on your own Stripe, or keep Zeffy for the forms and connect it. Either way, this is where the organization runs.

Questions people ask

Is All In One Nonprofit a Zeffy alternative?

For donation forms, event tickets, auctions, a store and donor records, it can be. They are not the same kind of product, though. Zeffy is a free fundraising platform. All In One Nonprofit covers the whole organization: board, compliance, finances, people and programs as well as fundraising.

Can we use Zeffy and All In One Nonprofit together?

Yes, and many organizations do. Connect your Zeffy account on My Organization and gifts collected on Zeffy arrive in your donor records and your books in All In One Nonprofit.

Does All In One Nonprofit ask donors for a tip?

No. The giving page runs on your own Stripe or PayPal account with no platform fee and no donor prompt. You pay your processor's card fees, and you can let donors choose to cover them.

How do the prices compare?

Zeffy is free to the organization and is funded by voluntary contributions from donors. All In One Nonprofit Essentials is $49 a month or $499 a year and All In One Nonprofit Complete is $199 a month or $1,999 a year.